Best Practice #9 – Agree on Criteria
One way to get beyond our worship wars over music preferences is to reach agreement on the criteria for judging “good music.” As the Sanskrit proverb says, “To judge a thing, one must first know the standard.”
It is possible to get beyond either-or thinking and find both-and mutually agreeable options without sacrificing anyone’s personal preferences. For example, it helps to use agreeable criteria about what constitutes “good music.” It can free us to select music on a basis other than whether it is either traditional, or contemporary, or blended or whether it meets our particular musical tastes.
Consider these criteria: if a hymn is singer-friendly, musically well-written, and theologically sound, then it qualifies as “good music.” This shifts our musical selections from arguments over particular musical styles and preferences to how well they match our mutually-agreeable criteria for “good music.”
Agreeing on criteria works for other challenging decision-making situations whether in our organizations, our work, or our personal relationships. For example, consider different preferences about when to arrive for work or where to do our work. Some of us are morning persons, and others are not. Some of us would prefer the flexibility to work from our office at home while others value in-person teamwork.
What would happen, though, if the workforce reaches agreement that what really matters is getting one’s work done in a timely manner, with quality outcomes, and with sufficient teamwork? That shifts decisions away from uniform starting times and work locations to flexible schedules and workplaces that meet mutually-acceptable standards of quality work outcomes, deadline constraints, and necessary teamwork.
Next time you reach an impasse over divergent preferences at work or at home, or in your organizational or personal relationships, see if you can move away from either-or solutions to setting agreeable criteria that can guide your decision-making with sufficient flexibility to reach satisfactory solutions that honor everyone’s diverging personal preferences.
[316 words]